• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Hamas invaded Israel 2023

  • Thread starter Thread starter McG
  • Start date Start date
A 2019 article on Liberal-Jewish relations.


When it comes to issues that matter to Jewish voters, it’s hard to deny that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has been active. He apologized for Canada’s refusal to admit the MS St. Louis, which carried Jews desperate to escape Hitler’s Europe. He’s maintained Canada’s Israel-friendly stance at the UN. His government worked with the Jewish state to modernize the Canada-Israel Free Trade Agreement. It also adopted the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s definition of anti-Semitism.

In 2016, Trudeau and the Liberals supported a parliamentary motion introduced by the Conservatives condemning the BDS campaign against Israel. The Liberals have also quadrupled funding to the Security and Infrastructure Program, which the Tories started to help at-risk communities protect themselves against hate crimes.

But while Harper’s Conservatives eliminated aid to UNRWA in 2010 over the agency’s ties to Hamas, the Liberals restored funding in 2016, to the tune of $110 million to date. That has stuck in many Jewish craws, especially given that other Western countries have stopped funding the agency. Scheer has also pledged to end it if his party forms the government.

Trudeau has embraced a pro-Israel stance, but has eschewed the more passionate rhetoric and tone used by the Conservatives, political scientist Steven Seligman argued in a paper published last year in The American Review of Canadian Studies.

In terms of substantive policy, the Trudeau government has made “only one change – the restoration of Canadian aid to UNRWA,” Seligman wrote.

Joe Oliver, a former Conservative cabinet minister under Harper, agrees that defunding UNRWA is important.

The agency, he said, is “outright hostile to Israel,” and tied to organizations that are banned in Canada. The schools, textbooks and media it funds openly call for the elimination of Israel. “It’s a shambles and a disgrace,” Oliver said. “Why are we continuing to fund that?”

For many Jewish voters, Scheer’s boldest promise was made in May, one day before Israel celebrated its Independence Day: to move Canada’s embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, a notion not even Harper floated. It came nine months after the Conservatives voted to recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and about a year after the United States moved its embassy to Jerusalem, which also coincided with Israel’s Independence Day.

The Liberals say Canada’s position on Jerusalem will not change. In a wide-ranging CJN interview last November, the prime minister said the only circumstance that would lead to him moving the embassy is a two-state solution worked out between Israel and the Palestinians “that is agreed to and stabilized. This is not a decision that can be made unilaterally by third parties, or even by one of the two parties. We need a two-state solution that is worked on by both parties to secure peaceful, democratic states on both sides.”

Overall, observed Weinfeld, it seems that some Canadian Jews “are doubtful of Trudeau the way some American Jews were doubtful of (former president Barack) Obama.” It’s possible, Weinfeld added, that Israel “may become more of a wedge issue in Canada among Liberal party members, the way it has in the U.S. among Jewish Democrats.”

Israel did become a wedge issue – and a heated one – during last year’s riots at the Gaza border, but it wasn’t among Liberals. Trudeau called for an independent investigation into Israel’s shooting of a Canadian doctor during the violence, and he was roundly condemned in some circles for failing to mention Hamas’ role in the fighting.

The episode led to an old-fashioned donnybrook in the House of Commons between him and Scheer.

The Conservative leader bluntly accused Trudeau of blaming the border rioting solely on Israel – “a country that goes out of its way to minimize civilian casualties” – without placing any blame on Hamas.

Trudeau replied that the Liberals have “repeatedly condemned the violence, including the incitement to violence by Hamas, but I will express once again that I am proud that Canada is one of those countries in which support for Israel and friendship with Israel go beyond partisan lines.”
Click to expand...

4 years later and the script seems familiar.

thecjn.ca

Inside the Jewish-Canadian election battleground

As the federal election kicks off, who will Canadian Jews vote for?
thecjn.ca thecjn.ca
 
OldSolduer said:
Not soon enough. I have a rather different approach to leaders of terrorist groups than the UN or the GoC .
Click to expand...

Martin Scorsese Casino GIF by Filmin
 
This makes the US, France, and the UK that have engaged Houthi drones.

I guarantee the Canadian government is disappointed we don't have a Frigate in that AOR right now.

www.ctvnews.ca

U.S. and Britain say their navies shot down 15 attack drones over the Red Sea

A U.S. warship shot down 14 suspected attack drones over the Red Sea on Saturday, and a Royal Navy destroyer downed another drone that was targeting commercial ships, the British and American militaries said
www.ctvnews.ca www.ctvnews.ca
 
Lumber said:
This makes the US, France, and the UK that have engaged Houthi drones.

I guarantee the Canadian government is disappointed we don't have a Frigate in that AOR right now.

www.ctvnews.ca

U.S. and Britain say their navies shot down 15 attack drones over the Red Sea

A U.S. warship shot down 14 suspected attack drones over the Red Sea on Saturday, and a Royal Navy destroyer downed another drone that was targeting commercial ships, the British and American militaries said
www.ctvnews.ca www.ctvnews.ca
Click to expand...

I'm sure you're right. And I'm sure solutions are being searched for.
 
Lumber said:
This makes the US, France, and the UK that have engaged Houthi drones.

I guarantee the Canadian government is disappointed we don't have a Frigate in that AOR right now.

www.ctvnews.ca

U.S. and Britain say their navies shot down 15 attack drones over the Red Sea

A U.S. warship shot down 14 suspected attack drones over the Red Sea on Saturday, and a Royal Navy destroyer downed another drone that was targeting commercial ships, the British and American militaries said
www.ctvnews.ca www.ctvnews.ca
Click to expand...

Would RCN have the ability to replenish any warshots it fired at this point?
 
Lumber said:
This makes the US, France, and the UK that have engaged Houthi drones.

I guarantee the Canadian government is disappointed we don't have a Frigate in that AOR right now.
Click to expand...
Are you sure about that? Do they want to be seen interfering with "Liberation Loitering Munitions" (LLM tm) on their way to support the oppressed Palestinians in their brave defiance of their oppressive Zionist overlords?
 
brihard said:
Would RCN have the ability to replenish any warshots it fired at this point?
Click to expand...
You mean replenish them in theatre? No, but yes. No one the ability to do that at sea, but the frigate could go alongside one of any number of friendly ports and replenish there. We'd just need to transport them over.

Do we have the ability to replenish our national stock? Not my wheelhouse.
 
GR66 said:
Are you sure about that? Do they want to be seen interfering with "Liberation Loitering Munitions" (LLM tm) on their way to support the oppressed Palestinians in their brave defiance of their oppressive Zionist overlords?
Click to expand...
Yes. Maybe a few of the more woke members of the LPC would be against it, but everyone else would. The whole reason CSC is getting Tomahawks is because Canada felt really left out when the US, UK and France were all lobbing missiles at ISIS and Canada couldn't contribute.

We're also the lead nation for ESSM, and the navy would LOVE to get some live use out of some Block 2s.
 
Lumber said:
This makes the US, France, and the UK that have engaged Houthi drones.

I guarantee the Canadian government is disappointed we don't have a Frigate in that AOR right now.

www.ctvnews.ca

U.S. and Britain say their navies shot down 15 attack drones over the Red Sea

A U.S. warship shot down 14 suspected attack drones over the Red Sea on Saturday, and a Royal Navy destroyer downed another drone that was targeting commercial ships, the British and American militaries said
www.ctvnews.ca www.ctvnews.ca
Click to expand...
You might be disappointed as well as the rest of the RCN but I guarantee you this Liberal GoC is not unhappy and some members in private are probably happy about not having a warship in the area.
 
In the early morning hours of December 16 (Sanna time) the US Arliegh Burke-class guided missile destroyer USS CARNEY (DDG 64), operating in the Red Sea, successfully engaged 14 unmanned aerial systems launched as a drone wave from Houthi-controlled areas of Yemen. The UAS were assessed to be one-way attack drones and were shot down with no damage to ships in the area or reported injuries. Regional Red Sea partners were alerted to the threat.
Click to expand...

 
OldSolduer said:
You might be disappointed as well as the rest of the RCN but I guarantee you this Liberal GoC is not unhappy and some members in private are probably happy about not having a warship in the area.
Click to expand...
The decision of what to deploy and where is ultimately a political decision.

The RCN is constantly being pushed to get ships ready and deployed sooner, including to this AOR.
 
Lumber said:
The decision of what to deploy and where is ultimately a political decision.
Click to expand...
Agreed - but I have seen a lot of kicking the can down the road behavior on defence matters by successive governments. of both political stripes.
 
I wonder how long before the Red Sea theatre becomes an operational test bed for laser weapons? The volume of munitions that can be put in the air in this day and age is definitely making a case for some air defense weapons that aren’t physical munitions based.
 
brihard said:
I wonder how long before the Red Sea theatre becomes an operational test bed for laser weapons? The volume of munitions that can be put in the air in this day and age is definitely making a case for some air defense weapons that aren’t physical munitions based.
Click to expand...
Not to mention cost. An SM-2 starts at ~0.5mil. How expensive are the drones that they are shooting down?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Jarnhamar
    • Wow
    • Like
    • Sad
Government now says new human rights chief did disclose key information about controversial social media posts
2
Replies
31
Views
2K
SeaKingTacco
SeaKingTacco
The Bread Guy
    • Like
Survey: "Two-thirds say inconsistent treatment from authorities favours some groups over others"
Replies
0
Views
1K
The Bread Guy
The Bread Guy
J
    • Like
Should Canada Stay in the U.N.? (split fm Hamas invaded Israel 2023)
2
Replies
28
Views
12K
Good2Golf
Good2Golf
Kirkhill
Active Protection Systems
Replies
6
Views
6K
Kirkhill
Kirkhill
A
Duration of getting back after medical in 2023
Replies
0
Views
4K
applicant23
A
Back
Top