- Reaction score
- 8,463
- Points
- 1,160
Getting your opinion out there...
Some of the bought & paid for media
- Thread starter The Bread Guy
- Start date
- Reaction score
- 372
- Points
- 930
Agree fully with both you and HT's post that you quoted.
I labeled him that way purposely, and two-fold. One, I am gatekeeping the concept of "journalism", specifically what I consider to be the requisite double/triple sourcing that accompanies "news", at least in the MSM. Jamie Vernon going to the internet to fact-check JR doesn't meet that bar, IMO.
The 2nd is to highlight the changing nature of where we get the information that is important to each of us, be it facts, opinion, education, edutainment, infotainment, or simple gossip. That landscape has shifted considerably in recent years.
I can definitely relate to JR. He is exactly where I was at in my 2nd and 3rd year of Uni - smoking joints with my buddies in some dorm room, talking shit about whatever thoughts were running through my head that day. We didn't even have the internet to refer to, to "fact check" things though. JR definitely has wide appeal though, that's undeniable.
- Reaction score
- 4,586
- Points
- 1,260
Lookit who's buying the Winnipeg Sun, as well as papers in Portage La Prairie and Kenora .....
globalnews.ca
Meanwhile, a bit of the REST of the story via the Globe & Mail (also archived here) ....
A bit more on Klein here (usual Wikipedia caveats apply)
en.wikipedia.org
Group led by former Manitoba cabinet minister to buy Winnipeg Sun - Winnipeg | Globalnews.ca
Postmedia Network Canada Corp. says it has signed a deal to sell the Winnipeg Sun to the Klein Group Ltd, a group headed by former Manitoba cabinet minister Kevin Klein.
globalnews.ca
A bit more on Klein here (usual Wikipedia caveats apply)
Kevin Klein (politician) - Wikipedia
QV
Army.ca Veteran
- Reaction score
- 3,349
- Points
- 1,010
Anyone else notice the lack of comments sections on media articles in CBC and National Post lately... I've noticed more and more there are fewer/almost no comment sections associated to posted articles. I quite enjoyed those because you could see over time, particularly this past year just how much the readers where calling out bullshit on the headlines or content on the politically charged articles. Even the comments on the CBC articles were highly critical of the "narrative" (Trudeau good, climate crisis, oil bad, CAF are rapey...etc). My tin foil hat says, this is just another step to control and regulate the message.
Yup, I’d say this. They’ve been replete with vitriol and abuse for years, to the point of outright attacks on reporters or subjects of articles. There’s no onus on the news organization to platform that.
- Reaction score
- 1,588
- Points
- 1,260
QV
Army.ca Veteran
- Reaction score
- 3,349
- Points
- 1,010
That would indeed be the Occam's Razor version, but it's just not as much fun.
Jarnhamar
Army.ca Myth
- Reaction score
- 7,331
- Points
- 1,160
CBC just ran a story about this fella.
CBC still hasn't seemed inclined to touch the story of the 10 Middle Eastern men kicking and stomping that lesbian couple in Halifax last month. I see stories by CTV, Global News, Hindustan Times from India.
No CBC.
Am I just missing the article?
Conservative MP attacked online after praising police for arrest in alleged homophobic crime
CBC still hasn't seemed inclined to touch the story of the 10 Middle Eastern men kicking and stomping that lesbian couple in Halifax last month. I see stories by CTV, Global News, Hindustan Times from India.
No CBC.
Am I just missing the article?
Last edited:
Wrong link, here’s the correct article: https://www.cbc.ca/amp/1.7257454
Twitter’s such an utter cesspool. For every one good faith comment or bit of discussion on anything like this there are probably dozens of anonymous trolls just slinging foul shit. Any politician who engages on there catches tons of it.
Jarnhamar
Army.ca Myth
- Reaction score
- 7,331
- Points
- 1,160
Thanks. That other link was showing up even after I edited and used the correct one multiple times.
I made a Twitter account just to see some of the links that get posted off of this site but ended up deleting my account recently.
I'll assume it's a case of Occam's razor why the CBC hasn't reported on the hate crime in Halifax last month. Not the unbiased kind of reporting I'd hope for from a tax payer funded broadcaster.
- Reaction score
- 4,586
- Points
- 1,260
Could be the same reason why those media outlets - and others that ran with the "Middle Eastern guys beating up someone in Canada" story - may not run with this one about the the Tory MP getting poked: can't run everything, and this doesn't fit their narrative or editorial priorities.
If there wasn't a social media post identifying the attackers as middle eastern or from Syria, that it was just some guys alleged to have attacked the two women, you think outlets like these would have run stories just as scathing?
Mob brutally beats lesbian couple celebrating a birthday
Emma MacLean, second from right, said she and her girlfriend, Tori, right, were attacked by a mob of about seven to 10 men while they were out celebrating one of their birthdays.
Lesbian couple beaten by group of men who allegedly yelled homophobic, degrading slurs
“I’m terrified to go downtown again in Halifax. I just feel like it’s so out of your control on what could happen,” she said.
nypost.com
Halifax police still investigating attack on lesbian couple by group of Middle Eastern men
Halifax police are requesting public assistance in identifying a group of Middle Eastern men who beat and injured a lesbian couple following a confrontation in the city’s downtown.
tnc.news
Mob of 'middle eastern men' brutally beat lesbian couple out celebrating a birthday
Terrifying video footage shows the moment a mob brutally beat a lesbian couple who were out celebrating one of their birthdays.
www.lbc.co.uk
Late edit to add: I'm also going to suspect these outlets won't carry the Tory MP story for similar "doesn't fit the editorial priorities" reasons.
A lesbian couple was brutally beaten by group of men in Halifax. Police still haven't filed charges
Two LGBTQ+ women are seeking justice after a group of men violently assaulted them over the weekend.
www.advocate.com
Lesbian couple beaten by group of men after birthday night out
A lesbian couple in Canada were allegedly beaten by a group of 10 men during a birthday celebration in Halifax.
www.thepinknews.com
Lesbian couple brutally beaten by men who were harassing them on one woman's birthday - LGBTQ Nation
The two women faced multiple injuries as a result of the attack
www.lgbtqnation.com
Jarnhamar
Army.ca Myth
- Reaction score
- 7,331
- Points
- 1,160
If 10 Caucasian men knocked a gay woman to the ground and started kicking her, especially during pride month? I'm not sure about how scathing the other news stories would be but I'll be willing to bet the CBC would have at least ran something. Probably quite scathing. And lots of "violent right wing attack!" type stuff.
They can't, but that doesn't pass the sniff test here IMO.
Brad Sallows
Army.ca Legend
- Reaction score
- 8,832
- Points
- 1,040
CBC could stand to run more plain ordinary news about unsettling events and waste less space detailing human interest angles designed to push emotions in order to support policy biases. It's a public broadcaster and should be covering all of the major "event" stories across the nation. A public sh!t-kicking administered by a group of men ganging up on a couple of women - forget the racial and sexual angles - is a major "event".
Colin Parkinson
Army.ca Myth
- Reaction score
- 12,388
- Points
- 1,160
There is a strong possibility that you are both right. The media is convinced that they know best and do not like their world being shaken. At the same time there is a real cost in time and wages to moderate. So two birds with one stone.
- Reaction score
- 4,586
- Points
- 1,260
Yup, I'd bet that way, too.
I should have been clearer. I threw in the "can't run everything" line because this is how ALL media preface descriptions of their editorial slant/policy/bias/approach/lens/triage factors.
You've hit the nail on the head with the bit in yellow. There's a case to be made that it's precisely the racial and sexual angles that, at least in part, trigger the "so, this worth running?" algorithm for these media. And it's interesting which is highlighted in which gang of stories.
For example, how many of these outlets would have carried a story as high up as they have if there was no racial element?
How many of these outlets would have carried the story without the sexual angle?Mob brutally beats lesbian couple celebrating a birthday
Emma MacLean, second from right, said she and her girlfriend, Tori, right, were attacked by a mob of about seven to 10 men while they were out celebrating one of their birthdays.www.dailymail.co.uk
Lesbian couple beaten by group of men who allegedly yelled homophobic, degrading slurs
“I’m terrified to go downtown again in Halifax. I just feel like it’s so out of your control on what could happen,” she said.Halifax police still investigating attack on lesbian couple by group of Middle Eastern men
Halifax police are requesting public assistance in identifying a group of Middle Eastern men who beat and injured a lesbian couple following a confrontation in the city’s downtown.Mob of 'middle eastern men' brutally beat lesbian couple out celebrating a birthday
Terrifying video footage shows the moment a mob brutally beat a lesbian couple who were out celebrating one of their birthdays.
As a thought experiment, based on the handling of the mass beating story, how about this story?A lesbian couple was brutally beaten by group of men in Halifax. Police still haven't filed charges
Two LGBTQ+ women are seeking justice after a group of men violently assaulted them over the weekend.Lesbian couple beaten by group of men after birthday night out
A lesbian couple in Canada were allegedly beaten by a group of 10 men during a birthday celebration in Halifax.Lesbian couple brutally beaten by men who were harassing them on one woman's birthday - LGBTQ Nation
The two women faced multiple injuries as a result of the attack
Why would both groups of outlets have difficulty figuring out why this doesn't fit their bias/lens/world view?
After all, the "defend the cops" angle might appeal to the first group, but why wouldn't they want to amplify this particular story? Also, the "a politician is supporting jumping on anti-gay shit" angle might appeal to the second cluster, but why wouldn't they want to amplify this particular story?
Good complicated case of venn diagrams of different editorial approaches from different outlets.
I'm not sure if there is a middle ground to be had in this.
On the one hand, not allowing the public to comment on current political theatre being reported on by a publically funded media organization seems downright wrong.
If the people are funding this organization with their tax dollars, the should be allowed to comment on the various stories that get published...
(If YouTube doesn't like the what's said in the comment section, they have their filters & algorithms to deal with the worst of it)
But on the other hand, I suspect you are right and it's easier to just turn the comment section off altogether.
It saves them the hassle of trying to police it themselves, and they aren't obligated to be a platform of the non-stop venom that people spew on the internet about politics.
(Especially with things like the Online Harms Bill on its way in that would leave them with massive fines potentially)
On the surface though, it's aggravated me for a long time that CBC will publish something on YouTube about politics & then not allow it's contents to be discussed.
It feels like I'm paying to be silenced by the same organization that seems to have more executive assistants getting bonuses than there are people in all of Canada.
RangerRay
Army.ca Veteran
- Reaction score
- 4,087
- Points
- 1,260
If one is seriously offended by the coverage provided by CBC, there are several ways to contact them and notify them of one’s displeasure. A comment section where anonymous bozos can spout off nonsense is probably not the best forum for that.
I think when comment sections were introduced, they were seen as forums for people to discuss the issue of the article in good faith. That did not happen. They quickly became forums for trolls, shills and crack-pots since they could remain anonymous.
I, for one, didn’t cry when comment sections were closed.
I think when comment sections were introduced, they were seen as forums for people to discuss the issue of the article in good faith. That did not happen. They quickly became forums for trolls, shills and crack-pots since they could remain anonymous.
I, for one, didn’t cry when comment sections were closed.
Similar threads
