The Sharp End

[Travis Silcox]

Has anybody ever read "The Sharp End: A Soldiers Story" by James R. Davis?

I‘ve only read a little bit of it and it sounded pretty good, a canadian soldier (from recruit to seargeant) tells his storys about rwanda, yugoslavia and someother places

anyways, have you read it, what do you think?

 

[Argyll_2347]

Yes! 3 times!

It‘s great! I am reading Fortune‘s Warriors by him right now.

Albainn Gu-Brath

 

[Tom Barrett]

Roger! Thought it was a pretty good account of things as they were. A little bit on the cowboy side though and some of the opinions expressed are open for discussion. Over all a great book. If you want to expand on it read. The Lion, the Fox and the Eagle.

 

[fusilier]

Well I read this book as well. It was a good read and gives a fairly good idea of what life is like in the infantry. However it is a lot different than that, not all of us are in recce platoon. As much as we wish we were

 

[Highlander]

I‘m new to the list, but if I can say anything about the Sharp End, it is that it‘s agreat book. All of you know how hard it is to describe the military and the emotions that soldiers get when they are doing their job, I think that Davis has done a really good job of it.

 

[Doug VT]

Davis is a good story teller, I‘ll give him that. But don‘t believe everything you read.

 

[aa]

I would just echo the point that you shouldn‘t believe everything that you read (obviously) and I can definitely say that applies to Jim‘s books.....I‘ll leave it at that.

 

[meathead]

Aside from the fact that you can not always believe what you read, I think it is great to have a book by a Canadian soldier about a Canadian Soldier. Even though I have never served with the Royal Canadian Regiment or in a recce platoon, being a fellow soldier there are aspects of his career I can relate to and that is the attractive aspect of the book. I would recommend it to anyone.

 

[noneck]

I have read both of the books The Sharp End and Fortunes Warriors. I find both of them to be well written and informative.In addition I think that it‘s great to have a Canadian soldier write about modern day soldiering. We need more of these types of educated rank and file soldiers to provide the Canadian public with an accurate portrayal of the profession of arms in Canada.

 

[brad_dennis]

Just finished re-reading this. After a second read, Davis appears to come across in print as an obnoxious, arrogant, know-it all. Despite this I have heard that he does tell it like it is.

I was wondering if anyone knew him and could give a another perspective on the book. Is it still accurate as it was written in 97 after the airborne disbandment

 

[Brad Sallows]

"Take it with a rock of salt" is advice I have read elsewhere.

In fact, considering the criticisms to which historians who access many sources are subjected, it should be a no-brainer to read guardedly the musings of any person from their unique subjective POV.

 

[Maverick]

http://www.chapters.indigo.ca/item.asp?Item=978155054588&Catalog=Books&N=35&Lang=en&Section=books&zxac=1

I just finished reading it and loved it.
Anyone have any thoughts on it? or new him?
He uses a lot of actual name referances (fact or fiction i dont know) from actual battalions and events etc...

I read this book to become more familiar with situations in the CFs as i am a PteR just entering my BMQ and i found it very informative.

 

[Born2Fly]

I think I've read that book about 3 times.


I proudly have it on my bookshelf.


I remember the first time I picked it up in a bookstore. I opened it to a random page, and read the first thing that I saw:


"Some people always have trouble shining their boots. I was one of those people."


I bought the book immediately after reading that. I too, was never good at shining my boots.


Excellent, excellent book. I'm never going to join the Infantry, but it's a good read none the less.

 

[armyrules]

Hey all I've recently purchased The Sharp End by JAmes R. Davies. I LOVE this book it really gives you an u=insight of what the military (army) is like in his point of view. I was just curious if anyone has read it. And for anyone wishing to read it I reccommend it all the way!!

 

[Cloud Cover]

His last name is Davis, not Davies.

The book is mediocre at best.

 

[armyrules]

Sorry with the spelling. IS there anything in particular you disliked about the book whiskey601?

 

[Cloud Cover]

Absolutely nothing. I guess that's why I called it mediocre. 

 

[Patrolman]

I read the book when I was in Bosnia in '99'. A good time filler that's about it. Maybe the story is a bit spoiled when you work with those who knew him. Most did not have much good to say. Besides it is hard to get excited reading about Nato Exercises in Germany.

 

[yamircr]

I read the book just recently, thought It was a great book, well written. Actually it brought alot of memories back, because I actually joined and went through training with James Davis. His facts  were correct I was present during some of them actually and brought back some good times and bad. I got a good laugh because he tells a story about myself and another soldier while we were posted in Germany.



Retired SGT 1 RCR

 

[SigOpDraco]

Finished the book this morning.

Cannot reflect from personal experience, but I thought it was a well written book. To me it was more experience and opinion from a soldier that came from outside of my mostly military family. The last page I thought was particularly motivating.

Hope I can find more like it.