- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 360
I tuned in to the US VP debates at CNN simply because I found them more interesting than the CBC debates between Harper, Duceppe, Layton, Dion and Elizabeth May.
When it came to the debate tonight, I thought that both seemed solid in spite of the disparity in experience between Biden and Palin. Still, I have a number of key points and observations that I would like to point out:
1.) Both essentially tried to defend their respective economic philosophies of themselves and their respective running mates, with Palin again emphasizing deregulation and the need for less government while at the same time going negative with the assertion that the Dems. will always increase taxes to fund huge government bureaucracy expansion. Biden responded in line with Obama's mantra that Dem.s actually intended just to raise taxes only for the rich and on corporations while at the same time cutting taxes for the middle class and working class Americans.
2.) When it came to the issue of climate change and energy, Palin thought that global warming was only partially caused by man and had more to do with the planet's cyclical climate changes, while Biden thought it was wholly caused by man- both did agree on the need for capping emissions. Interestingly, Biden pointed out that John McCain actually voted against that the same bills to drill for more oil that Barack Obama supposedly opposed.
-Palin actually said that Senator Biden opposed clean coal energy when Biden rebutted by saying he actually wholly supported it and even wanted to export it to countries like China to so that they can also reduce their emissions.
3.) Biden also pointed out that John McCain actually voted against the same legislation to fund the troops that Obama opposed simply because the bill contained the mention of a timeline to withdraw the troops- at timeline which McCain did not like because it was tantamount to defeat. Even Palin confirmed that by saying that setting a clear timeline was waving a white flag of surender, when Biden pointed that the current Bush government and the Iraqi government under PM Maliki were actually in talks right now to set a clear timeline to start withdrawing US troops form Iraq, which shows the support the Iraqi government has to Obama's timeline notion. Like Obama, Biden said that the war in Iraq was a mistake since the focus should have been ON AFGHANISTAN all along since that was where they began the war against the US.
- Palin also said that Obama said that US-Allied troops were just in Afghanistan destroying and bombing villages when Obama never said such a thing. Palin also said that both Al Qaeda spokesmen and General Petraeus both said that the central front in this war was Iraq, not Afghanistan, although Biden clearly disagreed by emphasizing that the central front sould have been on Afghanistan all along. Biden also said that General Mcllelan of the US forces in Afghanistan said that the surge strategy used in Iraq would not work and emphasized the need for more shoring up of the Afghan government and infrastructure as well as the redeployment of some troops in Iraq to Afghanistan, IIRC.
4.) Both emphasized that their respective campaigns did not support gay marriage, although Biden said that he thought it should be left just to the states to decide and both did seem to agree that civil unions short of marriage could still be eligible for some benefits, visitation rights, etc.
5.) Again, like McCain, Palin bashed Obama for wanting to meet with Pres. Achmedinijad of Iran to resolve some issues like Iran's stance on nuclear weapons and Israel, though Biden responded by saying that Achmedinijad did not even control the security apparatus in Iran- the THEOCRACY did- like their Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khamenei who was one of the successors to Ayatollah Khomeini who started the Iranian Revolution at the end of the 1970s, IIRC. He also emphasized that America's other allies had been actually pressuring on the US to meet with Iran's government for a while and that even the Bush administration after 5 years of just ignoring Iran actually sent a high delegate to joint talks with the Iranians and other nations in Switzerland, IIRC from what he said. Regardless, both stated that their respective camps would support Israel.
Another thing that I like about Senator Biden is that fact that he is a Liberal interventionist (meaning that one is willing to use the country's military for intervention in countries for reasons that don't necessarily serve America's interests, like peacekeeping/peacemaking missions that I infer that many of you here have a low opinion of) since Biden also stated that he was the one who introduced the notion in Congress to intervene in Bosnia during Clinton's time, a move which many Republicans opposed. He also said that he was willing to send US troops to Sudan to support the African Union peacekeepers there since it was the right thing to do; he said that he had actually been to the camps in Chad which housed the refugees from the genocide in Sudan and he even brought up the possibility of "no-fly zones" over Sudan, IIRC from the debate.
6.) Lastly, while both said that it would be a national tragedy , if elected, if their running mate was to die in office, both still did pledge to continue their colleague's policies if it ever came to that.
Overall, it was an interesting, intense debate like last week, and Palin seemed like a quick study on some issues, though from what I observed she seemed to give more anecdotes about her small town and governor experience and just some more meaningless platitudes-like saying that she was willing to tolerate others who differed from her views and saying she had a "diverse family"- but overall I think that Biden won not only by virtue of experience (or any bias on my part), but also because I thought that he gave clear, articulate and effective counterarguments to some of the negative accusations that she threw against his running mate(Biden gave some interesting arguments about how McCain is a false maverick).
And here is a CNN commentary about tonight's debate:
http://www.cnn.com/2008/POLITICS/10/02/vice.presidential.debate/index.html
When it came to the debate tonight, I thought that both seemed solid in spite of the disparity in experience between Biden and Palin. Still, I have a number of key points and observations that I would like to point out:
1.) Both essentially tried to defend their respective economic philosophies of themselves and their respective running mates, with Palin again emphasizing deregulation and the need for less government while at the same time going negative with the assertion that the Dems. will always increase taxes to fund huge government bureaucracy expansion. Biden responded in line with Obama's mantra that Dem.s actually intended just to raise taxes only for the rich and on corporations while at the same time cutting taxes for the middle class and working class Americans.
2.) When it came to the issue of climate change and energy, Palin thought that global warming was only partially caused by man and had more to do with the planet's cyclical climate changes, while Biden thought it was wholly caused by man- both did agree on the need for capping emissions. Interestingly, Biden pointed out that John McCain actually voted against that the same bills to drill for more oil that Barack Obama supposedly opposed.
-Palin actually said that Senator Biden opposed clean coal energy when Biden rebutted by saying he actually wholly supported it and even wanted to export it to countries like China to so that they can also reduce their emissions.
3.) Biden also pointed out that John McCain actually voted against the same legislation to fund the troops that Obama opposed simply because the bill contained the mention of a timeline to withdraw the troops- at timeline which McCain did not like because it was tantamount to defeat. Even Palin confirmed that by saying that setting a clear timeline was waving a white flag of surender, when Biden pointed that the current Bush government and the Iraqi government under PM Maliki were actually in talks right now to set a clear timeline to start withdrawing US troops form Iraq, which shows the support the Iraqi government has to Obama's timeline notion. Like Obama, Biden said that the war in Iraq was a mistake since the focus should have been ON AFGHANISTAN all along since that was where they began the war against the US.
- Palin also said that Obama said that US-Allied troops were just in Afghanistan destroying and bombing villages when Obama never said such a thing. Palin also said that both Al Qaeda spokesmen and General Petraeus both said that the central front in this war was Iraq, not Afghanistan, although Biden clearly disagreed by emphasizing that the central front sould have been on Afghanistan all along. Biden also said that General Mcllelan of the US forces in Afghanistan said that the surge strategy used in Iraq would not work and emphasized the need for more shoring up of the Afghan government and infrastructure as well as the redeployment of some troops in Iraq to Afghanistan, IIRC.
4.) Both emphasized that their respective campaigns did not support gay marriage, although Biden said that he thought it should be left just to the states to decide and both did seem to agree that civil unions short of marriage could still be eligible for some benefits, visitation rights, etc.
5.) Again, like McCain, Palin bashed Obama for wanting to meet with Pres. Achmedinijad of Iran to resolve some issues like Iran's stance on nuclear weapons and Israel, though Biden responded by saying that Achmedinijad did not even control the security apparatus in Iran- the THEOCRACY did- like their Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khamenei who was one of the successors to Ayatollah Khomeini who started the Iranian Revolution at the end of the 1970s, IIRC. He also emphasized that America's other allies had been actually pressuring on the US to meet with Iran's government for a while and that even the Bush administration after 5 years of just ignoring Iran actually sent a high delegate to joint talks with the Iranians and other nations in Switzerland, IIRC from what he said. Regardless, both stated that their respective camps would support Israel.
Another thing that I like about Senator Biden is that fact that he is a Liberal interventionist (meaning that one is willing to use the country's military for intervention in countries for reasons that don't necessarily serve America's interests, like peacekeeping/peacemaking missions that I infer that many of you here have a low opinion of) since Biden also stated that he was the one who introduced the notion in Congress to intervene in Bosnia during Clinton's time, a move which many Republicans opposed. He also said that he was willing to send US troops to Sudan to support the African Union peacekeepers there since it was the right thing to do; he said that he had actually been to the camps in Chad which housed the refugees from the genocide in Sudan and he even brought up the possibility of "no-fly zones" over Sudan, IIRC from the debate.
6.) Lastly, while both said that it would be a national tragedy , if elected, if their running mate was to die in office, both still did pledge to continue their colleague's policies if it ever came to that.
Overall, it was an interesting, intense debate like last week, and Palin seemed like a quick study on some issues, though from what I observed she seemed to give more anecdotes about her small town and governor experience and just some more meaningless platitudes-like saying that she was willing to tolerate others who differed from her views and saying she had a "diverse family"- but overall I think that Biden won not only by virtue of experience (or any bias on my part), but also because I thought that he gave clear, articulate and effective counterarguments to some of the negative accusations that she threw against his running mate(Biden gave some interesting arguments about how McCain is a false maverick).
And here is a CNN commentary about tonight's debate:
http://www.cnn.com/2008/POLITICS/10/02/vice.presidential.debate/index.html